Overall, the panelists (see profiles below including videos and links) were highly talented and accomplished but, for me, the program did not live up to its title and description of:
...illuminates questions about whether creativity is innate or learned, whether the innovative brain has distinct structural or chemical features, and whether we can enhance our ability -- and that of our children -- to be creative.
Part of the problem was that there were way too many panelists (eight) and too short a time (one hour and a half) for any of the speakers to shed light on the nature and source of creativity and genius. And part of the time that was available could have been better used to illustrate the specifics of brain research that were discussed such a Functional magnetic resonance imaging (fMRI), synesthesia and how scientists study and analyze brain activity. Good one-minute videos of these and related concepts could have nailed down these topics for audience participants.
And the implicit premise behind the panel is a bit far-fetched: Let's bring together neuroscientists and accomplished artists such as Bill T. Jones and Matthew Ritchie (profiles below) and have the scientists explain why the artists are brilliant. How can you really do that given some of the limitations of this program that I described above.
Bill T. Jones Does Collaborative Improvisation
My favorite part of the program was watching Bill T. Jones do a dance improvisation with cellist Chris Lancaster. Jones said to Lancaster: let's create a musical feeling to reflect upon President Lincoln's legacy. Jones then said his objective was to create as many different shapes as possible within a one-minute time frame.
Then, they started. It was a pleasure watching Jones improvise. Sometimes, he moved in a quick, fluid manner from one shape to the next and at other times, he would hold a pose for a fraction of a second before moving on.
I thought that this collaborative improvisation would have been a great springboard for discussion of the neurological basis of creativity, but I feel that this only happened to a limited extent.
The Battle Between Scientists and Artists
I think that Bill T. Jones and Matthew Ritchie were responding to what they felt was too much focus on the part of the neuroscientists on the operation of a single person's brain to understand the sources of creativity.
Ritchie was highly scornful of the notion that there are mad geniuses working in isolation who have their movie-made "aha" moments. The real world doesn't work that way, he said. Artists and others work with collaborators that they admire and ideas are generated from long hours of dedication and on-going exchanges.
Jones said that he was essentially a socialist and that we struggle with the nature of authorship. The best work that results from his collaborations do not come about because he has all the answers. It comes from multiple collaborators.
I think this idea of collaborative intelligence could have been explored more by the other panelists.
A Possible Alternative Approach for This Panel
I would have preferred to see a much smaller panel for this session. Maybe a moderator, an artist and a neuroscientist.
I'll pick Bill T. Jones to illustrate my idea. I would have based this program around short, improvisational dance demonstrations that Jones performed throughout this conversation.
So if the program opened with the improvisation that Jones did perform last, a good, non-rushed conversation could follow. Not one where the bar was set too high and the goal was to answer ultimate questions about how the brain works and sources of creativity. But for a meaningful, non-adversarial discussion about the creative process in action. As moderator I would simply ask, "Bill, what was going through your mind as you performed the improvisation." Then the neuroscientist, based on the latest research and insights from this field, might offer different ways of thinking about Jones' creative approach. And, I hope, an interesting in-depth conversation would emerge from these simple beginnings.
Maybe the Armitage Gone! Dance program I'm seeing Saturday night at the Guggenheim will be more along these lines.
Yes, I take issue with the structure and focus of last night's panel. But I think that all of the panelists have a wealth of knowledge and insight that I look forward to learning more about. I put together the following annotated bios of the speakers (with videos for all but one of the presenters). The bios themselves come from The World Science Festival website with some minor editing on my part.
Psychologist and biomedical engineer David Eagleman studies how humans perceive time as well as synesthesia, a condition in which stimulation to one sense triggers an involuntary response in others (seeing music in colors, for example). He is director of the Laboratory for Perception and Action and an assistant professor of neuroscience at Baylor College of Medicine. The following video about synesthesia features Professor Eagleman:
Saul Griffith
Saul Griffith is the president and chief scientist of Makani Power, a company that is seeking to harness clean energy from high-altitude wind. He is a 2007 MacArthur Award-winning inventor, entrepreneur and writer. Here's a video interview with Griffith in which he discusses his efforts to reduce his carbon footprint:
John Hockenberry - Moderator
John Hockenberry is an award-winning journalist with twenty-five years experience in radio, broadcast television and print. He is co-host of WNYC and PRI's The Takeaway, host on The DNA Files, and a contributor to The Infinite Mind. He is also a Distinguished Fellow at the MIT Media Lab. Hockenberry interviewed Kurt Vonnegut in Second Life in 2006 - Vonnegut's last sit down interview:
Bill T. Jones
Bill T. Jones, a Tony Award-winning choreographer and dancer, has changed the face of American dance. He has infused issues of identity, form and social commentary into hundreds of award winning shows worldwide. Jones is the artistic director and co-founder of the Bill T. Jones/Arnie Zane Dance Company in New York City.
Excerpts from Chapel/Chapter (2006):
Excerpts from The Breathing Show (1999):
Vilayanur Ramachandran
V.S. Ramachandran investigates the nature of self and human consciousness. His work spans the causes and effects of synesthesia and phantom limb pain to questions about visual perception and the brain. He is Director of the Center for Brain and Cognition at the University of California, San Diego. Ramachandran talks at 2007 Ted conference on "A journey to the center of your mind."
Matthew Ritchie
Matthew Ritchie is a painter, sculptor and digital artist. His work combines science, architecture, history, and the dynamics of culture to explore the idea of information, and is featured in the collections of numerous institutions, including MoMA and the Guggenheim Museum. In 2001, Time Magazine listed him as one of its 100 innovators for the new millenium. Ritchie profile on PBS's Art:21:
Michael York
Michael York has enjoyed a successful international acting career for over 40 years, creating an impressive body of work on stage, screen, and in the recording studio. As well as lecturing, he is the author of five books, including one on acting Shakespeare. And here is a brief glimpse and a single "shocking" word from Michael York in the closing minutes of Cabaret:
I'm excited about seeing this program, which was inspired by Brian Greene's popular book "The Elegant Universe." This performance combines two of my passions: dance and science. And I'm very interested in seeing how Karole Armitage and her dancers synthesize quantum mechanics and Einstein's theory of relativity.
Each program (Friday, May 30th and Saturday, May 31st) consists of a performance followed by a discussion featuring Armitage, composer Lukas Ligeti and physicist Jim Gates (May 30th) and Brian Greene (May 31st).
Background Videos for Armitage Program
Brian Greene gives a presentation about superstring theory at TED:
James Gates in an interview about Super Symmetry on PBS:
There are no dance videos of this upcoming performance, but you can watch a handful of profiles of dancers from Armitage Gone! Dance on their YouTube channel including this one of Mei-Hua.
