Great Dance
Great Dance Blog



September 20, 2007

Back to the Beginning - Modern Dance Class at 92nd Street Y

Update: 92Street Y blog write-up of this post.

I took a beginner modern dance class at 92nd Street Y last night - me and about 30 women - typical for many performing arts dance classes - as opposed to social dance classes. I still find this imbalance perplexing and I'd like to know if as few guys go to modern and ballet classes in other countries as they do here.

When I first started taking classes two years ago, I was very self-conscious about being the only guy in the class - or one of a few guys - and I thought that all my weaknesses would stand-out and be criticized - of course that never happened. Now my attitude is completely different. I'm so used to being one of only guys that it's just not something I think too much about. Plus, even though I'm a beginner dancer, I feel a thousand percent more comfortable moving, which makes taking classes much more relaxing and enjoyable.

So, the class I took last night was beginning modern with Susan Cherniak who danced with Eric Hawkins and teaches his technique (Erick Hawkins Dance Company). She's performing at 92nd Street Y's Harkness Dance Center in December. I liked the class - it was taught at nice, comfortable pace, was well within my experience and had live musical accompaniment from percussion player.

After taking classes for over two years, I feel like starting from the beginning again. Some of the modern and jazz classes I've taken have been too challenging for me - although fun - with the end result that I don't really have time to focus on the fundamentals because I'm struggling too much just to stay with the rest of the class. So I just want to take beginner classes like this one and have more time to develop my skills and technique. But most of all, I just want to move.

Posted by Doug Fox on September 20, 2007 6:31 AM

Trackback Pings

TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://greatdance.com/mtadmin/mt-tb.cgi/1548

5 Comments


Boris Willis said:

I wondered why men will generally take social dance class and not ballet or modern too. I am taking Viennese Waltz lessons at the French Embassy with about 200 people, half of them men. When we split from the women to learn the turns I realized that I was surrounded by men in a dance class and it was very strange. After a while I was aware of the social/sexual aspects of social dance class that is discouraged in modern and ballet class. In modern you dance by yourself most of the time and get approached by few during and after class. In the social dance setting women are coming up to me and asking me to dance and often telling me how much they like it when I take charge and twirl them around. I feel very manly.

Added: September 20, 2007 11:31 AM | Permalink

Tonya Plank said:

That's so cool that 92Y blogged about your blog! Funny too, because I was going to take that class and opted for another one instead. Generally, I feel more comfortable at the Y than anywhere else -- the other studios I find very intimidating, particularly Steps on Broadway! The Y generally seems pretty mellow and the students non-competitive and non-judgmental. I used to take ballet with Merceditas Manago-Alexander (who was in that Sara Rudner thing we saw). I loved her class and she was an excellent teacher and I highly recommend her for ballet if you ever want to take that; ballet for me unfortunately just become too hard on my hips.

Drunk men at social dance competitions have told me that one of the reasons they love to take social is so they can put their hands all over women's bodies and have it be socially acceptable. Gross. This is one of the reasons so many women opt for the huge expense of private lessons; we HATE that. Men who take social dance are rarely very serious about actually learning to dance, yet most women are. It's very difficult to learn to dance when you have as partners people who just want to touch you in places they shouldn't be (you wouldn't believe how many men do not know what a shoulder blade is - that's where they're supposed to hold you, NOT farther down; you cannot "lead" someone by their butt) and aren't the least bit interested dance as an art form. It's really too bad that more men aren't.

Added: September 20, 2007 2:05 PM | Permalink

neil said:

first year professional training 1 guy to 24 girls!!

2-3rd years 4 guys to 20 girls!!

Added: September 20, 2007 2:40 PM | Permalink

Anna Brady Nuse said:

Yeah, and then you look at how many men head major dance companies vs women and suddenly the demographic completely flips. What's that about?

Here's some interesting research on dancenyc's site called The Gender Project: http://www.dancenyc.org/upload/chapter/407_Pdf_3_researchdata.pdf

Added: September 20, 2007 6:15 PM | Permalink

Tonya Plank said:

What I meant to say above, and not sure if it was clear, is that I think the social dancing classes are not really about dance, to the men, though they are to the women. I also think homophobia has something to do with men not taking ballet and modern and those kinds of dance classes, at least in adulthood. I don't really understand it, but I've been told by a few that they're afraid of being around gay men in class.

Anna, that's really disturbing. Horribly, stats like that make me not want to like ballet as well as I do. I also feel, from what Neil said, that male dancers must have it so much easier than female. Makes me want to root for the women more.

Added: September 21, 2007 12:00 AM | Permalink

Leave a Comment



© 2007 Great Dance. All rights reserved.
Great Dance is a registered trademark.